Short answer: it's unsettled. Like the rest of the US, New York has no law that squarely legalizes or bans online mystery boxes — but state gambling rules and each platform's own terms both matter. Here's the New York-specific picture.
New York is one of the two states with an active lawsuit against Packdraw alleging the pack-opening model is unlicensed gambling. That litigation makes New York the clearest flashpoint for mystery-box legality in the US right now.
How US gambling law applies
New York courts weigh the standard three-part test — consideration, chance, and prize. Mystery boxes arguably satisfy all three, which is the basis of the active lawsuits against Packdraw nationally. The counter-argument is that you always receive an item of value. Until the courts rule, New York's position stays uncertain. See our national US legality guide and are mystery boxes gambling? for the full reasoning.