How We Score
The same rubric, applied to every site. No brand pays for placement.
The Scoring Rubric
Boxes & Prizes
20%Range, quality, and real value of the boxes and prizes on offer.
Odds & Fairness
25%Provably-fair systems, transparent odds, and verifiable outcomes.
Value & Bonuses
15%Welcome offers, promo codes, and ongoing value for money.
Trust & Safety
20%Licensing, reputation, security, and how the platform treats users.
UX & Design
10%Usability, speed, and clarity of the opening experience.
Payouts
10%Withdrawal options, speed, and reliability of payouts.
Our Process
- 1 We sign up and deposit our own money
- 2 We open boxes across price points
- 3 We test payouts and withdrawal speed
- 4 We verify provably-fair systems
- 5 We re-score every site monthly
Our Data
Beyond editorial scoring, we publish refreshed data from public sources. Every figure on the site carries its source and the date we last fetched it. Fetchers run on a schedule and commit the data — an outage never changes a score.
| Source | What we take | Cadence | Last fetch | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Uptime checks | Whether each brand site responds | Daily | Nov 20, 2026 | A Cloudflare wall reads as "bot-protected", not down. A closure is only confirmed by a human. |
| RDAP | Domain registration date and registrar | Weekly | Nov 16, 2026 | Registry data; some fields are redacted. |
| Companies House | UK company status, incorporation, officers, filings | Weekly | not yet collected | UK-registered operators only. We never publish an officer’s birth date. |
| Wayback Machine | First archived snapshot (site age) | Weekly | Nov 16, 2026 | Archive coverage is uneven; we keep the last good value. |
| CourtListener | Federal court records matching a brand | Weekly | not yet collected | Many state suits are not indexed; we note when nothing matches. |
| iTunes Search | iOS app rating and seller, when an app exists | Weekly | not yet collected | Term search returns look-alikes; we only record a verified seller. |
| DefiLlama | Volume, fees and revenue for crypto gacha platforms | Daily | Nov 20, 2026 | Aggregate only; no wallet-level profit/loss on the free tier. |
| Skinport | CS2 market prices for case-EV math | Daily | Nov 20, 2026 | Median prices only; 8 requests per 5 minutes. |
| ByMykel CSGO-API | CS2 case contents, rarities and float ranges | Weekly | Nov 16, 2026 | Open data (MIT); knife/glove tiers are generic types, priced by averaging finishes. |
No Paid Placements
A site's score can never be bought. Editorial scoring and any future commercial relationships are kept strictly separate — see our affiliate disclosure.
Who Scores the Sites
The Mystery Boxes Editorial Team
Independent Reviewers
We sign up, deposit, open boxes, and test payouts on every platform we score — then re-score monthly. No brand pays for placement.